來自專業刊物的意見...about oscar award

看板Movie-Score (電影電視劇配樂討論)作者mesple (OB)時間19年前 (2007/03/02 00:27)推噓1(1推 0噓 1→)

留言2則, 2人參與討論串1/1

最近在網路上發行的一份電影音樂雜誌 http://www.filmmusicweekly.com/ 對今年奧斯卡電影音樂獎做出如下評論大意是說，奧斯卡獎從來沒有被認真對待過，至少不曾從歷史的觀點來看得獎者以及得獎作品。今年的得主GS，他拿了兩座奧斯卡獎，是Jerry Goldsmith，Georges Delerue， Elmer Bernstein的兩倍，如果Ennio Morricone的終身成就獎算一座的話， GS也是顏大師的兩倍。作者一直希望JG可以拿一座終身成就獎，但也沒等到更正：JG過世也兩年了，所以很令人感慨啊～ The Oscar – no lesson in history The big question is: are the music Oscars really meant to be taken seriously? No doubt about it, Gustavo Santaolalla has definitely come up with some very effective and original music for the two films resulting in his Oscars: Brokeback Mountain and Babel. But when you look at the Oscars from a historical perspective, you begin to wonder how important these awards really are. Jerry Goldsmith got one. Elmer Bernstein got one. Georges Delerue got one. Leonard Rosenman didn’t get any. Until yersterday, Ennio Morricone owned zero. Gustavo Santaolalla now now has two, twice as many as Ennio. And Jerry. And Elmer. I’m not saying that Santaolalla’s music isn’t good – on the contrary, I think it’s pretty effective in its right context, but let’s face it: the Oscars simply don’t give you a very good overview of the most important film scores from a historical viewpoint. And I know, who said that was the purpose...? Still, it ’s sad to see that composers who really changed the way film music was conceived, composers who influenced generations, never got the recognition they deserved. I was waiting for years and years for Jerry Goldsmith to get the lifetime achievement award, but it never happened. So, I sincerely hope that everyone takes the Oscars with a grain of salt. Let ’s just say it was a nice party – and congratulations, Gustavo Santaolalla, on your second Oscar! Mikael Carlsson Editor editor@filmmusicweekly.com -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 59.112.32.37