PTT影音娛樂區 / WesternMusic

[新聞] 告示牌嚴詞重批艾薇兒Hello Kitty MV

看板WesternMusic作者 (Love, Warrior.)時間12年前 (2014/04/24 04:08), 編輯推噓50(50推 0噓 43→)
留言93則, 48人參與, 7年前最新討論串1/1
標題直接下 "Avril Lavigne 'Hello Kitty' Video Is An Embarrassment In Any Language" 副標題是：Why, Avril? Why? 告示牌形容這首歌是專輯裡最爛的一首歌 但這支MV放上YouTube卻馬上被撤下 顯示這支MV比歌曲本身是更大的災難 唯一稱讚到的是像Skrillex的髮型 但也說這個優點馬上被其「無恥的鏡頭」抹煞掉了 歌曲中段刻意採用了dubstep 告示牌卻痛批如此不潔的作法 應該叫驅魔神探康斯坦丁來淨化一下 老實說我也覺得那段dubstep真的很莫名其妙 最後也提到希望艾薇兒能夠推出另外一支MV作為這張不叫好不叫座的專輯結尾 因為再爛也不會比這支爛 而且連提兩次「對吧？」真的是很酸 來看一下這支大災難MV http://youtu.be/avMo9ssoQL0
http://ppt.cc/Q49G Avril Lavigne 'Hello Kitty' Video Is An Embarrassment In Any Language By Jason Lipshutz, N.Y. | April 22, 2014 5:34 PM EDT Why, Avril? Why? "Hello Kitty" is the weakest song on Avril Lavigne's fifth studio album, a grating earworm that squeezes Gwen Stefani's Japan fetishization into an even more unseemly package. But in a lot of ways, its music video, which wormed its way onto YouTube on Tuesday (Apr. 22) and then was quickly taken down, is even a bigger train-wreck than the track itself. Click here to watch the gloriously ghastly video on Lavigne's web site. The majority of the "Hello Kitty" music video finds the Canadian pop princess parading around with four identical, creepily expressionless Asian women behind her, performing mind-numbingly generic dance moves, in locales like a bedroom, a candy store and a street. When she's not commanding her vaguely offensive troop, Lavigne is clumsily playing guitar, wearing glasses, eating sushi, waving at admirers, taking a single photograph, and… not much else, really. The Skrillex-y hair with pink highlights wins the singer back a few points, but the shameless camera-mugging quickly makes them evaporate. So, wait, how is the "Hello Kitty" video even more abhorrent than the song, which has a dubstep breakdown so unholy that Keanu Reeves probably battled it in "Constantine"? Well, the music videos previously released from Lavigne's largely dismissed new album have been pretty excellent, actually. The clip for "Here's To Never Growing Up" was an enjoyably cheeky nod to Lavigne's sk8er boi beginnings, while the guest star-laden "Rock N Roll" visual allowed the singer to battle comic-book scum with imaginative gusto (and Billy Zane). Even the video for the schlocky Chad Kroeger duet "Let Me Go" was fittingly overdramatic and well-produced. The first three videos from "Avril Lavigne" varied in ambition, but one could feel the singer trying to accomplish a real effect with each clip, be it nostalgia, appreciative chuckles or the plucking of Canadian heartstrings. The "Hello Kitty" video tries to do nothing. Its laziness is demonstrated in the first 21 seconds, during which Lavigne holds a plush stack of cupcakes, shakes her hips, stares at the cupcakes, bounces her shoulders, and then, when she sings the line "Someone chuck a cupcake at me"… tosses the fake cupcakes at the camera, her lip movement not matching up to the backing track whatsoever. Cool! Hopefully Lavigne will release another video from "Avril Lavigne" before that album cycle ends, because that underrated LP cannot die with the pained whimper of this "Hello Kitty" video. Maybe she'll make a video for the Marilyn Manson duet "Bad Girl"; it can't be worse than this, right? Right? -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 59.115.194.189 ※ 文章網址: http://www.ptt.cc/bbs/WesternMusic/M.1398283728.A.6C7.html
推
04/24 07:07, , 1F
歌曲好聽與否見人見智，因為我滿喜歡那段Dubstep的XDD
04/24 07:07, 1F
→
04/24 07:08, , 2F
只是這MV完全不知所云到一個極致,沒品質,拍攝手法也糟
04/24 07:08, 2F
→
04/24 07:08, , 3F
有沒有人有八卦這支MV到底出了什麼事...= =????
04/24 07:08, 3F
推
04/24 09:04, , 4F
其實還好欸 這種MV風格某些日本歌手也是頗愛拍....
04/24 09:04, 4F
→
04/24 09:05, , 5F
什麼tommy february6之類的
04/24 09:05, 5F
推
04/24 10:09, , 6F
雖然我也不太喜歡這首歌和MV 但好像也沒嚴重到需要告示牌
04/24 10:09, 6F
→
04/24 10:10, , 7F
發一篇文更開批判吧...但也算是一種另類行銷就是了~
04/24 10:10, 7F
→
04/24 10:10, , 8F
公開
04/24 10:10, 8F
推
04/24 10:13, , 9F
如果不是Avril 其實這種不知所云的MV也滿常見的阿
04/24 10:13, 9F
推
04/24 10:38, , 10F
根本負面行銷吧 反正已不紅了沒差
04/24 10:38, 10F
推
04/24 10:45, , 11F
這MV很糟嗎?怎麼覺得還好,類似色彩繽紛編舞奇怪不知所云的
04/24 10:45, 11F
→
04/24 10:46, , 12F
MV到處是啊!日本自己也一堆類似的吧?雖說她不太適合裝泡泡
04/24 10:46, 12F
→
04/24 10:47, , 13F
糖偶像,但被罵成這樣還說MV冒犯日本文化有點過了吧?
04/24 10:47, 13F
推
04/24 10:58, , 14F
現在被批種族歧視了，#avrilracist 在 twitter上面串聯
04/24 10:58, 14F
→
04/24 11:00, , 15F
這首歌真的整張專輯最難聽
04/24 11:00, 15F
推
04/24 11:40, , 16F
卡卡卡卡哇伊
04/24 11:40, 16F
→
04/24 11:45, , 17F
也還好吧 只是沒什麼特別的 不知所云的MV其他人也一堆阿
04/24 11:45, 17F
推
04/24 12:20, , 18F
有那麼嚴重嗎……？
04/24 12:20, 18F
推
04/24 12:28, , 19F
根本就是文化霸權在看這mv 歧視何在？
04/24 12:28, 19F
推
04/24 12:34, , 20F
開始負面行銷了吧 畢竟麥莉很成功
04/24 12:34, 20F
→
04/24 12:38, , 21F
原來比爾伯會批判阿XD
04/24 12:38, 21F
推
04/24 12:55, , 22F
我滿喜歡這首歌的 不過Billboard無聊發神經也不是一天兩
04/24 12:55, 22F
→
04/24 12:57, , 23F
天的事了 像前兩年Ri和CB有意復合傳聞 告示牌還公開寫信
04/24 12:57, 23F
→
04/24 12:58, , 24F
給他們倆位 我也看不出來這MV哪裡種族歧視?
04/24 12:58, 24F
推
04/24 13:18, , 25F
我以為這是kyary pamyu pamyu的MV
04/24 13:18, 25F
推
04/24 13:23, , 26F
被刪了...剛跑去優酷看，感覺整個MV都卡卡的!?
04/24 13:23, 26F
推
04/24 13:31, , 27F
歧視?哪裡啊 其實聽久了還蠻喜歡卡卡卡卡哇亦
04/24 13:31, 27F
→
04/24 13:50, , 28F
只有台灣日本在聽她的歌吧XDDDD
04/24 13:50, 28F
推
04/24 13:55, , 29F
其實也還好吧~~這次專輯MV都好young XD
04/24 13:55, 29F
推
04/24 13:58, , 30F
很像這女人
04/24 13:58, 30F
推
04/24 14:34, , 31F
真正有種族歧視的言論不反 反這個?! twitter用戶怎麼了
04/24 14:34, 31F
推
04/24 14:53, , 32F
第一次聽超瞎 現在有點洗腦XD 告示牌是太閒嗎
04/24 14:53, 32F
推
04/24 16:03, , 33F
其實筆者也是當初很愛Avril 看到她變成這樣不勝唏噓吧
04/24 16:03, 33F
推
04/24 16:54, , 34F
我覺得好好聽耶，我有病XD
04/24 16:54, 34F
推
04/24 17:06, , 35F
覺得還好耶
04/24 17:06, 35F
推
04/24 18:57, , 36F
說他種族歧視是說mv內容對民族跟文化的刻版印象近乎到嘲弄的
04/24 18:57, 36F
→
04/24 18:57, , 37F
地步。
04/24 18:57, 37F
推
04/24 19:16, , 38F
不過今天全美各大媒體都報導，點閱數也很好，負面行銷大成功
04/24 19:16, 38F
→
04/24 19:16, , 39F
對他來說還是利多吧，不然本來全世界市場只剩下日本了～
04/24 19:16, 39F
推
04/24 20:13, , 40F
哪裡有種族歧視阿...?
04/24 20:13, 40F
→
04/24 20:33, , 41F
看不到mv了嗚嗚
04/24 20:33, 41F
推
04/24 20:43, , 42F
這mv不會想看第二次
04/24 20:43, 42F
推
04/24 20:48, , 43F
這類型MV蠻常見的阿 我覺得還好 但歌真的難聽到靠杯
04/24 20:48, 43F
推
04/24 20:58, , 44F
臉部癱瘓的舞者們真的很好笑XD
04/24 20:58, 44F
推
04/24 21:21, , 45F
雖然這次負面滿成功的XD 但還是覺得告示牌自認為的種族
04/24 21:21, 45F
→
04/24 21:23, , 46F
歧視很可笑XD 日本新聞都說這支MV的團隊和導演都是日本
04/24 21:23, 46F
→
04/24 21:24, , 47F
人 告示牌不會覺得自己被打臉嗎XD
04/24 21:24, 47F
推
04/24 22:52, , 48F
臺灣演唱會結束就跑去日本拍這首，是時間太趕？
04/24 22:52, 48F
→
04/24 22:53, , 49F
這主題可以有更好的發揮，只是MV拍得很無聊
04/24 22:53, 49F
→
04/24 23:13, , 50F
mv跟歌都讓我無法忍受..........
04/24 23:13, 50F
推
04/24 23:37, , 51F
不過這個算專欄吧 但是也不太喜歡這種尖刻文章就是
04/24 23:37, 51F
→
04/24 23:44, , 52F
這張真的是整張最難聽的一首....
04/24 23:44, 52F
推
04/24 23:46, , 53F
本來對這首歌就沒有很喜歡，所以MV也是不期不待，沒想到...
04/24 23:46, 53F
推
04/25 00:03, , 54F
MV沒看過不評論,但歌其實還蠻有趣不錯聽啊~XD
04/25 00:03, 54F
推
04/25 00:43, , 55F
Avril 用大笑來回應了～
04/25 00:43, 55F
推
04/25 00:56, , 56F
看完只有三個字 老番顛 但也不覺得有這麼嚴重
04/25 00:56, 56F
推
04/25 01:11, , 57F
歌和MV都很囧 可是根本看不出種族歧視阿= =
04/25 01:11, 57F
→
04/25 01:12, , 58F
剛看比爾伯更新 Avril回應了
04/25 01:12, 58F
推
04/25 01:15, , 59F
都和日本人和作 也找日本人拍MV了 哪來歧視阿........
04/25 01:15, 59F
→
04/25 01:16, , 60F
日本人覺得被種族歧視的話 還願意幫忙拍這種MV= =
04/25 01:16, 60F
→
04/25 01:26, , 61F
樓上 其實並不是找xx人拍 xx人就不是被歧視 這邏輯不太對
04/25 01:26, 61F
→
04/25 01:27, , 62F
例如中東人在好萊塢中會扮演的通常是恐怖份子 這是歧視。
04/25 01:27, 62F
→
04/25 01:28, , 63F
或說 是種讓人不舒服的刻板印象
04/25 01:28, 63F
→
04/25 01:29, , 64F
但這支真的看不太出來哪裡歧視了啊？若說後面伴舞故意裝成
04/25 01:29, 64F
→
04/25 01:30, , 65F
藝妓表情也太牽強,也沒塗白粉點紅唇,更沒有醜化什麼啊？
04/25 01:30, 65F
→
04/25 01:31, , 66F
抱歉我其實沒耐心看完全片XD 根據我看的那一半也沒看出歧視
04/25 01:31, 66F
→
04/25 01:31, , 67F
就是了~~ 我只是想說不是演了就一定不是歧視
04/25 01:31, 67F
推
04/25 01:36, , 68F
並不是只有演了 是這個MV是日本的製作團隊和"導演"這樣
04/25 01:36, 68F
→
04/25 01:36, , 69F
邏輯應該說得通了吧
04/25 01:36, 69F
推
04/25 02:09, , 70F
不覺得歧視啊...這也太小題大作了吧...西方國家多得是更嚴
04/25 02:09, 70F
→
04/25 02:09, , 71F
重的嘲笑東方文化吧= =
04/25 02:09, 71F
推
04/25 02:15, , 72F
MV很日本沒歧視，歌有夠恐怖...What the hell?!
04/25 02:15, 72F
→
04/25 03:52, , 73F
話說我超討厭所有會出現功夫、忍者元素的西方mv...
04/25 03:52, 73F
→
04/25 03:52, , 74F
雖然不一定有嘲諷意味 但有些真的很不倫不類XDDDD
04/25 03:52, 74F
→
04/25 03:52, , 75F
btw其實我覺得這mv沒有真的糟成文章寫得這樣 可是歌...
04/25 03:52, 75F
→
04/25 03:53, , 76F
實在很少讓我這麼難以忍受的 好可怕....
04/25 03:53, 76F
推
04/25 11:04, , 77F
跟樓上同感 看到一些怪異的東方元素MV 就不禁覺得現在資
04/25 11:04, 77F
→
04/25 11:05, , 78F
訊這麼發達 還會出現這些狀況 突顯西方還是很自我中心
04/25 11:05, 78F
→
04/25 19:19, , 79F
這首真的聽不下去...
04/25 19:19, 79F
推
04/25 21:19, , 80F
看完以後只覺得她大崩壞....
04/25 21:19, 80F
→
04/25 21:31, , 81F
無感QQ可以打下一首了
04/25 21:31, 81F
推
04/25 23:52, , 82F
覺得好KESHA XDDD
04/25 23:52, 82F
推
04/26 01:27, , 83F
因為太奇怪了我看了10次還被洗腦(救命)
04/26 01:27, 83F
推
04/26 07:29, , 84F
當年唱I'm with you 的艾薇兒如果穿越時空看到這個MV
04/26 07:29, 84F
→
04/26 07:29, , 85F
不知道會作何感想
04/26 07:29, 85F
→
04/26 09:54, , 86F
故意出爛歌博版面的可能性?
04/26 09:54, 86F
推
04/26 12:25, , 87F
還是 Let it go 那首無論歌還是MV都很棒~
04/26 12:25, 87F
推
04/27 11:35, , 88F
不覺得有歧視啦，只是整支MV很廉價的FU
04/27 11:35, 88F
推
04/27 12:34, , 89F
樓樓上是說Let Me Go吧?
04/27 12:34, 89F
推
04/27 19:44, , 90F
是 Let me GO 才對~XD
04/27 19:44, 90F
推
04/27 22:18, , 91F
這張專輯首波Here走正經路線,第二主打Rock走搞笑路線
04/27 22:18, 91F
→
04/27 22:19, , 92F
第三主打走感人路線 以上全部GG 沒路可走只好冒險一試
04/27 22:19, 92F
→
01/16 18:03, 7年前 , 93F
都和日本人和作 也找日 https://noxiv.com
01/16 18:03, 93F
‣ 更多 braveshsu 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1JM1tGR7 (WesternMusic)
WesternMusic 近期熱門文章
更多 近期熱門文章 >>
PTT影音娛樂區 即時熱門文章
更多 即時熱門文章 >>
‣ 更多 braveshsu 的文章
文章代碼(AID): #1JM1tGR7 (WesternMusic)