[討論] PR與THG的相似點已回收

看板movie (電影)作者Lester116 (Lester)時間13年前 (2013/07/15 22:34)推噓1(4推 3噓 7→)

留言14則, 11人參與討論串1/1

近幾天的亂況不禁讓人想起去年飢餓遊戲上映的情形飢餓遊戲(The Hunger Games) V.S. 大逃殺(Battle Royale) 現在則是環太平洋(Pacific Rim) V.S. 福音戰士(Evangelion) 基本重點大致圍繞在原創?致敬?抄襲幾個相似點如下 ●作者為了不受影響而未觀看過另一部作品 THG：小說作者從未聽過BR這部小說與電影，直到有人跟她提起。而當她向編輯詢問是否該去閱讀時，編輯為了不讓她腦中的世界觀受影響，否決這個提議。[1] PR：導演從未看過EVA，雖然有工作人員提供DVD資料，但他不希望受影響而拒絕觀看。[2] ●支持者能接受作品有更早之前文獻的影子，但無法接受是向更新作品的致敬 THG：實境生存秀、希臘神話、伊拉克戰爭鏡頭(作者自述)[3] 魔鬼阿諾(The Running Man)、蒼蠅王 PR：鐵人28號、機動警察、怪獸(Kaiju)電影(作者自述)[4] 無敵鐵金剛、トップをねらえ! ●部份情況，大逃殺or福音戰士被看做是不入流的作品大逃殺：噴血惡搞的B級亂殺片福音戰士：阿宅看明日香○○自high的卡通 ●疑似被致敬的爭議作品擁有高IMDB分數大逃殺： 7.8 [5] 福音戰士2.0： 7.8 [6] ●疑似被致敬的爭議作品擁有好萊屋導演或演員的粉絲大逃殺：昆丁塔倫提諾心目中1992-2009年內的第一名電影作品是《大逃殺》[7] 福音戰士：羅賓威廉斯是個Eva粉，並在電影《不速之客》中提供自己的量產初號機模型做客串[8] --- [1] http://ppt.cc/de4K “I had never heard of that book or that author until my book was turned in. At that point, it was mentioned to me, and I asked my editor if I should read it. He said: ‘No, I don’t want that world in your head. Just continue with what you’re doing.’ ” She has yet to read the book or to see the movie. [2] http://ppt.cc/e1Cm I've got to ask — are you an Evangelion fan? "That's one of the four animes I've never seen." 詳細譯文可參閱本板 #1HudS-Sl 或 #1HuhCXsw [3] http://ppt.cc/WhWs [4] http://youtu.be/amgChYCs8f8?t=1m

[5] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0266308/ [6] http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0860906/ [7] http://youtu.be/Zv0WlHbBhdc?t=1m

[8] http://youtu.be/V5FmFaK7pMU

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0265459/trivia?ref_=tt_ql_2 "Robin Williams is a fan of the Japanese anime series Shin seiki evangerion and specifically asked to have a model from the series incorporated as part of the film. " http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neon_Genesis_Evangelion "Robin Williams briefly discussed the series in-character in the 2002 film One Hour Photo, mistakenly identifying the Mass-Production Evangelions as "heroic robots that fight the monsters." Williams used a toy from his personal collection and added that line intentionally; as a fan of the series, he knew the comments would enrage fellow fans watching the movie." -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.116.20.106