[影評] The Little Mermaid 影評分享

看板movie (電影)作者Vulpix (Sebastian)時間1周前 (2023/05/26 04:44)推噓62(62推 0噓 40→)

留言102則, 60人參與討論串1/1

節錄幾則影評，給雅琪。 https://reurl.cc/Ov1ryv Detroit Times It's the latest line item on Disney's bid to redo its entire animated library, and it never feels motivated by anything other than corporate interests. It's flat, dramatically vacant and visually inert, with a lead performance that all too closely resembles a fish out of water. 迪士尼努力重製整個動畫庫，其最新專案就是小美人魚，而除了企業利益之外，沒有任何其他動機。這部片扁平不立體、空虛到誇張、視覺上沒有活力，還有主角的表演實在太如魚不得水。 That's Halle Bailey of musical duo Chloe x Halle in the lead role, and she's in entirely over her head as Ariel, a mermaid who is enamored with the world above sea level and wants to become human. At least that's what we're told and we remember from the original, as Bailey occasionally smiles and bats her eyes but is incapable of making audiences feel any emotion in her character's journey. The 2-D animated Ariel had greater depth and more soul behind her eyes than Bailey is able to muster. 來自音樂雙人組 Chloe x Halle 的海蠣貝蜊正是那個主角，她完全陷入愛麗兒這個愛上陸地並且想要變成人類的人魚角色之中了。至少我們是這樣被告知的，而且看過原版的我們一定記得這件事。海蠣偶爾笑一下、眨眨眼，但還是無法讓觀眾感受到她所扮演的角色的一絲情感。比起海蠣，二維動畫裡的愛麗兒的雙眼更有深度也更有靈魂。 ===== 這篇沒有正面稱讚海蠣的聲音，只有提到讓海蠣無聲是臭棋。 ===== https://reurl.cc/b95YMM The New York Times It reeks of obligation and noble intentions. Joy, fun, mystery, risk, flavor, kink — they’re missing. The movie’s saying, “We tried!” Tried not to offend, appall, challenge, imagine. 它散發著一股義務味和崇高意涵。歡樂、樂趣、神秘、風險、味道、糾結——它們都不見了。電影像是在說：「我們努力過了！」盡量不冒犯、不嚇人、不挑戰、不發揮想像力。 ===== 上面是爛蕃茄擷取的文字。 ===== Now Ariel is in the singer Halle Bailey’s hands. And it's not that she can't keep par with the original’s illustrators. It’s that this movie isn’t asking her to. It takes the better part of an hour for the flesh-and-blood Ariel to go mute. And when she does, whatever carbonation Bailey had to begin with goes flat. This Ariel has amnesia about needing that kiss, taking “ cunning” off the table for Bailey, too. 現在愛麗兒被交給海蠣貝蜊這個歌手來演。不是她不能跟原版人設一樣，事實上這部電影就沒有要求她如此。有血有肉的愛麗兒被噤聲超過半個小時，在此期間，無論海蠣有多強的爆發力都只能流於平淡。這個愛麗兒對於她需要那個親親非常健忘，而這也把「俏皮」這個特質從海蠣身上抽掉了。 With her sister, Bailey is half of the R&B duo Chloe x Halle. They’ve got a chilling, playful approach to melody that Bailey can’t fully unleash in this movie. For one thing, she’s got two songs, one of which — the standard “ Part of Your World” — does manage to let her quaver some toward the end. But what’s required of her doesn’t differ radically from what Jodi Benson did in the first movie. Ostensibly, though, Bailey has been cast because her Ariel would differ. Bailey’s is Black, with long copper hair that twists, waves and locks. Racially, the whole movie’s been, what, opened up? Diversified? Now, Ariel’s rueful daddy, King Triton, is played by a stolid Javier Bardem, who does all the king’s lamenting in Spanish-inflected English. Instead of the Broadway chorines of the original, her mermaid siblings are a multiethnic, runway-ready General Assembly. 海蠣是節奏藍調雙人組 Chloe x Halle 的半身，另一半是她姊姊。兩人合力演唱時的旋律悠閒而且活潑有趣，但海蠣在片中無法完全展現。她有兩首歌，其一就是那首標準的「Part of Your World」，有讓她在最後發揮顫音。但是對她的要求與當年原版電影中對茱蒂班森的要求沒有什麼很大的不同，雖然表面上來說，海蠣被選上是因為她的愛麗兒會有所不同。海蠣是黑人，有著捲曲、波浪、紮成髒辮的古銅色長髮。就種族而言，整部電影好像，怎麼說呢，很開放？很多樣化？愛麗兒她那個後悔的父親，川頓國王，由冷淡的哈維爾巴登飾演並用西班牙腔的英語發出感嘆。而與百老匯舞臺上的歌舞團也不同，她的人魚姊姊們是多種族的，隨時可以開聯合國大會。 ===== 這篇對音樂的出發點還算有趣，像是對黃種人饒舌感到有點不適之類的。然後他其實一直在替海蠣打抱不平。 ===== https://lwlies.com/reviews/the-little-mermaid/ Little White Lies Speaking of tropical seas, this is very much the Caribbean, not Denmark, like the Hans Christian Andersen original or the vague Europe of the animated feature. While casting Halle Bailey as a Black Ariel raised some eyebrows, and debating the race of a character that is half fish is a task for the bowels of the internet, transposing the action to the early 19th century in the Caribbean is a wild choice. 都提到熱帶海域了，這很大程度像是加勒比海，不是安徒生原著的丹麥或原版動畫的架空歐洲。雖然讓海蠣出演愛黧兒的確令人吃驚，至於爭論半魚半人的角色種族則是網路空間裡的事項，但把整部片搬到十九世紀初期的加勒比海真的太瘋狂了。 The nobility all have English accents (including his Black mother, white Prince Eric is adopted, because sure), while the locals have Caribbean accents, drink from coconuts and play steel drums. There’s something unintentionally hilarious to having our little Black mermaid falling in love with a handsome Prince who talks endlessly about increasing the Caribbean island’s trade with Portugal and Brazil because, erm… what are you trading there, buddy? 貴族全都使用英國腔（包括王子的黑人媽），而當地人都操著加勒比口音、喝著椰子水、打著鋼鼓。英俊的王子無止盡地談論著如何增加加勒比海島與葡萄牙和巴西的交易，雖然不是故意的，但讓小黑人魚愛上這樣的英俊王子似乎很可笑，因為，呃……到底你們在交易啥鬼啊？ ===== 下一段的第一個字就是錯字，我笑死。川頓國王的角色名變成 Titan 了～這篇的重點是捧女主角並且說設定爛死了、太奇怪了，然後瑜不掩瑕這樣。 ===== 影評真的求生欲望都很強烈。當然，有黑人血統的的確也對海蠣更友善，即使給負評也都一定是錯不在她。但總歸是有人努力批評女主角演技了。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc), 來自: 163.13.112.58 (臺灣) ※ 文章網址: https://www.ptt.cc/bbs/movie/M.1685047441.A.4BB.html ※ 編輯: Vulpix (163.13.112.58 臺灣), 05/26/2023 04:48:32

推

Dcwei

05/26 05:21, 1周前 , 1^F

05/26 05:21, 1^F

王子有點大隻，除非王子是裝在另一個胃裡吧。

推

taohjca

05/26 05:34, 1周前 , 2^F

05/26 05:34, 2^F

其實他講那段，是想說「你看，有趣的東西就是可能會讓某些人不開心」。所以為了不讓所有人不開心，電影就變得不有趣了。然後他還想看 Disney 為此道歉 34 年XD ※ 編輯: Vulpix (163.13.112.58 臺灣), 05/26/2023 05:48:42

推

icexfox

05/26 06:35, 1周前 , 3^F

05/26 06:35, 3^F

推

f1rc

05/26 07:06, 1周前 , 4^F

05/26 07:06, 4^F

推

holyseraph

05/26 07:06, 1周前 , 5^F

05/26 07:06, 5^F

推

madeathmao

05/26 07:06, 1周前 , 6^F

05/26 07:06, 6^F

→

holyseraph

05/26 07:07, 1周前 , 7^F

05/26 07:07, 7^F

推

santiago148

05/26 07:17, 1周前 , 8^F

05/26 07:17, 8^F

推

yoshilin

05/26 07:18, 1周前 , 9^F

05/26 07:18, 9^F

推

santiago148

05/26 07:21, 1周前 , 10^F

05/26 07:21, 10^F

推

welkin0105

05/26 07:52, 1周前 , 11^F

05/26 07:52, 11^F

→

welkin0105

05/26 07:53, 1周前 , 12^F

05/26 07:53, 12^F

推

madeathmao

05/26 07:54, 1周前 , 13^F

05/26 07:54, 13^F

推

SINW

05/26 08:11, 1周前 , 14^F

05/26 08:11, 14^F

推

godofsex

05/26 08:14, 1周前 , 15^F

05/26 08:14, 15^F

→

Wall62

05/26 08:26, 1周前 , 16^F

05/26 08:26, 16^F

而且是頂級影評。

推

devilkool

05/26 08:29, 1周前 , 17^F

05/26 08:29, 17^F

→

ccas

05/26 08:31, 1周前 , 18^F

05/26 08:31, 18^F

推

Krishna

05/26 08:32, 1周前 , 19^F

05/26 08:32, 19^F

推

auron4041

05/26 08:51, 1周前 , 20^F

05/26 08:51, 20^F

推

tavern

05/26 08:54, 1周前 , 21^F

05/26 08:54, 21^F

推

silverowl

05/26 08:56, 1周前 , 22^F

05/26 08:56, 22^F

推

LordOfCS

05/26 09:05, 1周前 , 23^F

05/26 09:05, 23^F

推

christ1125

05/26 09:06, 1周前 , 24^F

05/26 09:06, 24^F

推

GEKKAKAJIN

05/26 09:07, 1周前 , 25^F

05/26 09:07, 25^F

推

neak

05/26 09:14, 1周前 , 26^F

05/26 09:14, 26^F

→

neak

05/26 09:14, 1周前 , 27^F

05/26 09:14, 27^F

→

neak

05/26 09:14, 1周前 , 28^F

05/26 09:14, 28^F

推

lpb

05/26 09:16, 1周前 , 29^F

05/26 09:16, 29^F

→

kelon

05/26 09:18, 1周前 , 30^F

05/26 09:18, 30^F

→

paradisaea

05/26 09:24, 1周前 , 31^F

05/26 09:24, 31^F

→

jqs8ah5ar

05/26 09:26, 1周前 , 32^F

05/26 09:26, 32^F

→

jqs8ah5ar

05/26 09:27, 1周前 , 33^F

05/26 09:27, 33^F

→

jqs8ah5ar

05/26 09:29, 1周前 , 34^F

05/26 09:29, 34^F

推

paradisaea

05/26 09:31, 1周前 , 35^F

05/26 09:31, 35^F

推

b160160

05/26 09:32, 1周前 , 36^F

05/26 09:32, 36^F

還有 33 則推文

→

holyseraph

05/26 11:01, 1周前 , 70^F

05/26 11:01, 70^F

→

holyseraph

05/26 11:01, 1周前 , 71^F

05/26 11:01, 71^F

→

holyseraph

05/26 11:01, 1周前 , 72^F

05/26 11:01, 72^F

→

holyseraph

05/26 11:01, 1周前 , 73^F

05/26 11:01, 73^F

推

bysy2322

05/26 11:09, 1周前 , 74^F

05/26 11:09, 74^F

→

neiger

05/26 11:13, 1周前 , 75^F

05/26 11:13, 75^F

→

neiger

05/26 11:14, 1周前 , 76^F

05/26 11:14, 76^F

送女兒出嫁、出航，然後 https://youtu.be/hoQEddtFN3Q

。這個結局應該還算正向。

推

richardplch

05/26 11:33, 1周前 , 77^F

05/26 11:33, 77^F

→

richardplch

05/26 11:33, 1周前 , 78^F

05/26 11:33, 78^F

改。關於爆米花桶：這個世界上有六種人有買票給好評的人、有買票給差評的人、有買票沒評論的人、沒買票給好評的人、沒買票給差評的人、沒買票沒評論的人。人數各自設為 x,y,z,a,b,c 吧，肯定 c 是佔大多數，但也是最不重要的。認證評價可以視為：x/(x+y) = 95% 所有評價可以視為：(x+a)/(x+y+a+b) = 49% 平均各自落在 4.7/5 分和 2.8/5 分。（前一段時間的數據是 95% 48% 4.7 2.7）如果詳細一點去統計人數的話應該可以分析，但我好懶。有人爬過了嗎？粗略來看就是 5 分和 1 分在互懟，然後願意進場的多數給 5 分。或者說，因為無視缺點才給 5 分，也因為無視缺點才進場。 1 分則是狂怒居多。我？當然是狂怒的那種。

推

babyMclaren

05/26 12:34, 1周前 , 79^F

05/26 12:34, 79^F

推

Jin63916

05/26 12:38, 1周前 , 80^F

05/26 12:38, 80^F

昨天有篇很棒的推文，借來用，改了字。本來是蛤蜊貝蠣。

推

g0820413

05/26 12:49, 1周前 , 81^F