Re: [TVs4] Top 8 Live result

看板AmericanIdol作者zeohealer (傑歐)時間11年前 (2013/05/30 00:31)推噓1(1推 0噓 2→)

留言3則, 2人參與討論串2/3 (看更多)

看到大家對這次的淘汰結果相當義憤填膺，順道轉幾篇外網(http://www.rollingstone.com )對於這週TV表演的看法，幾週看下來感覺他們的評論比較中立，對於淘汰人選的預測也還滿準確的。原文網址：http://ppt.cc/85Mx 關於本周八強的表演（附上一些重點整理）這篇文章的作者認為本周最佳無疑是Team Usher的眼鏡姐，最差的則是Team Shakira的Sasha Allen。對Adam組的評論： Up until last night, we were sure Judith Hill was a shoo-in for the finals. But her self-professed "risky" rendition of "#thatpower" by will.i.am featuring Justin Bieber gave us pause. Could she be sent packing this week? As for the rest of Adam's team, we were once again disappointed by Sarah Simmons, who sang Gotye's "Somebody That I Used to Know." 直至上周以前，他們十分肯定Judith將鎖定決賽的一席名額，但是本週冒險的選曲可能會因此把這位具職業光環的唱將給送回家。至於Sarah，又是一次令人失望的演出！ Adam本週意圖打造"plan strategic moment"，但是顯然沒有成功。對Blake組的評論： Doe-eyed Danielle Bradbery is clearly his frontrunner. Her performance of "Grandpa" by the Judds was an easy-to-swallow pill even for people who aren't into the genre. Meanwhile, for the first time this season, Holly Tucker proved she has what it takes to go the distance too. Before last night, we thought she'd be the next to go, as she's somewhat interchangeable with Amber, but now we think she may have done (pun intended) just enough to squeak by this week. We also expect the Swon Brothers to stick around. Their acoustic version of the Eagles' "Seven Bridges Road" while seated around a bonfire suited them well. 親女兒顯然是這比賽的frontrunner，她親和力十足的演唱為她掙得不少美國人民的投票。同時，他們認為Holly本週亮眼的演出很有機會幫助她再次撐過這一週。對於兄弟組合，他們同樣預測本週能夠安全度過。接著是結果秀部分（大致附上一些重點）原文網址：http://ppt.cc/G2iV 儘管文章的作者同樣對於本週的淘汰人選感到吃驚，但是認為這結果依然是有跡可循， Judith的選歌並沒有幫助她與觀眾產生連結，她的職業背景也確實不利於在選秀節目中走遠。至於Sarah，他們並不滿意她這週的表現，但原本預期是由Sasha取代此一淘汰的位置。 =============================================== 看到版上許多人認為Team Blake的選手表演很無趣，或是認為沒有實力，單純靠著廣大的死忠鄉村票倉躺晉，實際上這邊需要澄清一點，過去Blake帶出來的冠亞軍沒有一人是鄉村掛的前三季裡也沒有任何一位鄉村選手進入到六強... 所以認為鄉村票神通廣大的想法並不實際！這季他的選手能夠走遠，感覺還是靠著在適當的時機選對歌曲， Blake對於自己選手的定位相當精準。這邊只是希望大家在支持自己喜歡的選手之餘，也盡量少攻擊其他的人。 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 140.138.230.220