[閃亮]至今心得
怎麼辦
既然是光陰二
很難不跟光陰一比較
一比較
就真的覺得編導演都差很多
我也很想鼓勵閃亮
可是又有點覺得不那麼甘願
畢竟有褒有貶比較有助於進步
一味鼓勵顯得瞎了點
本劇設定其實跟光陰一的元素很接近
版上很多觀眾也注意到了
一定有個快樂又充滿父愛母愛的家(方家等同光陰一的孫家)
這個家有個單純幸福的孩子
但不知怎地
也許是編劇使然
一美感覺俠氣傻氣加單純,卻並不覺得她笨(反而是大智若愚吧)
但以安目前為止除了以上形容詞以外,他的單純其實比較接近白目跟小笨
(比方今天的爆料,還沒演就知道他要爆,難以令人期待)
然後會有個心酸的家庭(佩芬家,跟茜茜一樣要扛起經濟重擔,還要有個白目妹妹
,姐妹衝突的設定又有一點像娟娟和茜茜)
然後會有個只會依附男人的女人(張媽和陳媽)
家裡有錢有勢討人厭但不是壞人的(成才和小甜甜、朱媽和成媽)
元素設定相近,可是效果有差
我覺得一方面是失去新鮮感
一方面是各主角的表演比較浮面
像在演戲(光陰一自然許多,像在生活)
一方面是情節有點粗
讓人很難感動得起來
比方說一個設定考上第一志願的聰明男孩要去找心愛女友
怎麼會願意帶妹妹在颱風天去冒生命危險,又有可能被疑瓜田李下而抓包
我不用考上第一志願都不會這麼做了
感覺像為了爆梗而爆梗
觀眾怎麼會有感覺
和佩芬的雨中相會更是沒必要
本來人家佩芬好好的反而因為你鎮宇要來可能陷入危險
這樣一來除了感覺男主角白目以外不會有什麼浪漫Fu
說實話
雖說梁正群是第一次演戲情有可原
可是只有為難和不爽兩種表情實在難以扛起這個角色的複雜和重任
相對於楊一展層次分明的演出......
那個一直被罵的品章反而是整部戲比較像十八歲的少年
我個人欣賞他衝動的自然
至今我只喜歡方家夫妻的對手戲
但只有他兩人可看,整部片重心有點失衡阿....
批評不單純只為批評
只希望未來編劇多注意一下邏輯和角色設定
別讓年輕主角自己打自己嘴巴
還會繼續看的
劇組加油!!
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 219.91.102.38
→
09/09 23:06, , 1F
09/09 23:06, 1F
→
09/09 23:11, , 2F
09/09 23:11, 2F
→
09/09 23:12, , 3F
09/09 23:12, 3F
推
09/09 23:21, , 4F
09/09 23:21, 4F
推
09/09 23:32, , 5F
09/09 23:32, 5F
→
09/09 23:32, , 6F
09/09 23:32, 6F
→
09/09 23:32, , 7F
09/09 23:32, 7F
推
09/09 23:33, , 8F
09/09 23:33, 8F
推
09/09 23:35, , 9F
09/09 23:35, 9F
→
09/09 23:35, , 10F
09/09 23:35, 10F
→
09/09 23:37, , 11F
09/09 23:37, 11F
推
09/09 23:38, , 12F
09/09 23:38, 12F
推
09/09 23:41, , 13F
09/09 23:41, 13F
→
09/09 23:41, , 14F
09/09 23:41, 14F
→
09/09 23:41, , 15F
09/09 23:41, 15F
→
09/09 23:48, , 16F
09/09 23:48, 16F
推
09/09 23:49, , 17F
09/09 23:49, 17F
→
09/09 23:49, , 18F
09/09 23:49, 18F
→
09/09 23:50, , 19F
09/09 23:50, 19F
推
09/09 23:50, , 20F
09/09 23:50, 20F
→
09/09 23:50, , 21F
09/09 23:50, 21F
→
09/09 23:51, , 22F
09/09 23:51, 22F
→
09/09 23:51, , 23F
09/09 23:51, 23F
→
09/09 23:51, , 24F
09/09 23:51, 24F
推
09/09 23:53, , 25F
09/09 23:53, 25F
→
09/09 23:53, , 26F
09/09 23:53, 26F
→
09/09 23:54, , 27F
09/09 23:54, 27F
推
09/09 23:54, , 28F
09/09 23:54, 28F
推
09/09 23:54, , 29F
09/09 23:54, 29F
→
09/09 23:54, , 30F
09/09 23:54, 30F
→
09/09 23:54, , 31F
09/09 23:54, 31F
→
09/09 23:55, , 32F
09/09 23:55, 32F
→
09/09 23:56, , 33F
09/09 23:56, 33F
→
09/09 23:57, , 34F
09/09 23:57, 34F
推
09/09 23:57, , 35F
09/09 23:57, 35F
→
09/09 23:57, , 36F
09/09 23:57, 36F
→
09/09 23:57, , 37F
09/09 23:57, 37F
→
09/09 23:57, , 38F
09/09 23:57, 38F
→
09/09 23:58, , 39F
09/09 23:58, 39F
→
09/09 23:59, , 40F
09/09 23:59, 40F
→
09/10 00:00, , 41F
09/10 00:00, 41F
→
09/10 00:00, , 42F
09/10 00:00, 42F
→
09/10 00:01, , 43F
09/10 00:01, 43F
推
09/10 00:08, , 44F
09/10 00:08, 44F
推
09/10 01:05, , 45F
09/10 01:05, 45F
→
09/10 01:07, , 46F
09/10 01:07, 46F
→
09/10 01:09, , 47F
09/10 01:09, 47F
推
09/10 01:16, , 48F
09/10 01:16, 48F
推
09/10 01:21, , 49F
09/10 01:21, 49F
→
09/10 01:23, , 50F
09/10 01:23, 50F
→
09/10 01:24, , 51F
09/10 01:24, 51F
→
09/10 01:25, , 52F
09/10 01:25, 52F
→
09/10 01:26, , 53F
09/10 01:26, 53F
→
09/10 01:27, , 54F
09/10 01:27, 54F
推
09/10 01:37, , 55F
09/10 01:37, 55F
→
09/10 01:39, , 56F
09/10 01:39, 56F
→
09/10 01:40, , 57F
09/10 01:40, 57F
→
09/10 01:42, , 58F
09/10 01:42, 58F
→
09/10 01:43, , 59F
09/10 01:43, 59F
推
09/10 04:07, , 60F
09/10 04:07, 60F
→
09/10 14:37, , 61F
09/10 14:37, 61F
→
09/10 14:40, , 62F
09/10 14:40, 62F
→
09/10 14:41, , 63F
09/10 14:41, 63F
→
09/10 15:31, , 64F
09/10 15:31, 64F
→
09/10 15:31, , 65F
09/10 15:31, 65F
→
09/10 15:51, , 66F
09/10 15:51, 66F
→
09/10 18:06, , 67F
09/10 18:06, 67F
→
09/10 18:07, , 68F
09/10 18:07, 68F
→
09/10 18:07, , 69F
09/10 18:07, 69F
→
09/10 18:09, , 70F
09/10 18:09, 70F
→
09/10 18:23, , 71F
09/10 18:23, 71F
→
09/10 18:23, , 72F
09/10 18:23, 72F
推
09/10 18:35, , 73F
09/10 18:35, 73F
→
09/10 18:36, , 74F
09/10 18:36, 74F
→
09/10 18:37, , 75F
09/10 18:37, 75F
→
09/10 18:38, , 76F
09/10 18:38, 76F
※ 編輯: cfeet 來自: 219.91.107.231 (09/10 20:53)
→
09/10 21:03, , 77F
09/10 21:03, 77F
→
09/10 21:04, , 78F
09/10 21:04, 78F
推
09/10 23:37, , 79F
09/10 23:37, 79F
推
09/11 13:19, , 80F
09/11 13:19, 80F
→
09/11 13:19, , 81F
09/11 13:19, 81F
→
09/11 13:19, , 82F
09/11 13:19, 82F
推
09/11 13:21, , 83F
09/11 13:21, 83F
推
09/11 13:41, , 84F
09/11 13:41, 84F
討論串 (同標題文章)
CTV 近期熱門文章
PTT影音娛樂區 即時熱門文章
43
161