Re: [AI. ] Top 3 Performances
看板Realityshow (真人實境秀)作者ladyluck (Luck be a lady)時間18年前 (2008/05/14 23:25)推噓102(102推 0噓 149→)留言251則, 22人參與討論串8/9 (看更多)
※ 引述《DREW (曖曖內含光)》之銘言:
先感謝 DREW 大的歌單。
這週我先聽了MP3再看了電視,從這兩遍的印象來談。
Round 1 (judge picks)
David Archuleta - And So It Goes (Billy Joel) picked by Paula
Syesha Mercado - If I Ain't Got You (Alicia Keys) picked by Randy
David Cook - The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face (Roberta Flack) picked by
Simon
第一輪我會給小弟,雖然我不覺得這首歌非常合他風格,
技巧上他唱得很棒,編曲和曲式上也適合他。
但是情感上,很抱歉,稍嫌不對味。
為何我會這麼說呢?請看這首歌的歌詞:
In every heart there is a room
A sanctuary safe and strong
To heal the wounds from lovers past
Until a new one comes along
I spoke to you in cautious tones
You answered me with no pretense
And still I feel I said too much
My silence is my self defense
And every time I've held a rose
It seems I only felt the thorns
And so it goes, and so it goes
And so will you soon I suppose
But if my silence made you leave
Then that would be my worst mistake
So I will share this room with you
And you can have this heart to break
And this is why my eyes are closed
It's just as well for all I've seen
And so it goes, and so it goes
And you're the only one who knows
So I would choose to be with you
That's if the choice were mine to make
But you can make decisions too
And you can have this heart to break
And so it goes, and so it goes
And you're the only one who knows
這是一首描述破裂邊緣婚姻的歌曲,
對於消逝的愛的無助,只能說 And so it goes,
這是種很成人的感情,曾經滄海難為水的淡淡哀愁,
小弟唱的感覺雖然努力想要感人,但不對味啊不對味。
殺下不差嘛!比我想像得要好,也比她在 The One 裡好,
至少今天音準沒有阿飄,但是 bridge 那段唱得沒有味道,
高潮就拱不上去,而我還是不喜歡高音用吼的。
大廚,前半段他唱得很平實,照理說這裡應該要展現歌唱功力,
但是大廚就是平實....,甚至低音處還是有點黏糊糊的老問題。
我個人以為大廚的問題是,在唱歌時很多小地方的處理太直接不夠細膩,
就靠著最後吼兩聲讓大家高潮。
不過這首歌Simon其實選得不錯,大廚就是適合本來不是搖滾的歌,
給它加點搖滾元素。
Round 1:弟>殺=廚
Round 2 (personal pick)
David Archuleta - With You (Chris Brown)
Syesha Mercado - Fever (Peggy Lee)
David Cook - Dare You to Move (Switchfoot)
小弟這首 With You 根本是追著樂隊跑,邊跑邊喘氣,
還要很突兀地 R&B 鬼叫兩聲,說起來 R&B 真的不是他的菜啦!
不過選了首新歌勇氣可佳,加油啦!
只有我覺得殺下的發燒唱得還不錯嗎?
音準有到位又很愛演,可以啦!
百老匯經理人有在看嗎?不過聽說 Rent 要下檔了。
大廚,其實唱得還不錯,雖然低音一開始走得有些離譜,
但那大概就是大廚的個人風格了。(茶)
基本上我覺得這不是首適合 AI 的歌,
沒有旋律的歌,在 AI 舞台上唱起來也不會有多大共鳴。
2nd round: 殺下>=小弟=大廚
Round 3 (producer's choice)
David Archuleta - Longer (Dan Fogelberg)
Syesha Mercado - Hit Me Up (Gia Farrell)
David Cook - I Don't Want to Miss a Thing (Aerosmith)
Simon批評小弟的根本是非戰之罪,
這是製作人選的,那你要小弟拿把電吉他揮兩下嗎?
我很喜歡小弟的 Longer 啊!
他就是適合這樣純淨簡單不耍花招的歌曲。
殺下,這首真的砸了,很努力想炒熱場子,
但看起來就她一個在自嗨....
大廚唱得還不錯,但泰勒叔叔鬼吼還是比較厲害,
問問你的好兄弟澳男,看他唱了泰勒叔叔的歌之後多慘。XD
編曲不佳,表演倒很有明星味。
個人很不愛這首歌(cheeeeeeeesy),但我知道很多人很愛,可以搶票。
Round 3:弟>廚(這是因為我不愛這首歌)>殺
用腳指頭猜都知道誰會走。
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 68.5.45.161
→
05/14 23:25, , 1F
05/14 23:25, 1F
推
05/14 23:27, , 2F
05/14 23:27, 2F
→
05/14 23:27, , 3F
05/14 23:27, 3F
→
05/14 23:27, , 4F
05/14 23:27, 4F
推
05/14 23:27, , 5F
05/14 23:27, 5F
→
05/14 23:28, , 6F
05/14 23:28, 6F
→
05/14 23:28, , 7F
05/14 23:28, 7F
→
05/14 23:28, , 8F
05/14 23:28, 8F
→
05/14 23:29, , 9F
05/14 23:29, 9F
→
05/14 23:30, , 10F
05/14 23:30, 10F
→
05/14 23:30, , 11F
05/14 23:30, 11F
→
05/14 23:31, , 12F
05/14 23:31, 12F
→
05/14 23:31, , 13F
05/14 23:31, 13F
→
05/14 23:32, , 14F
05/14 23:32, 14F
→
05/14 23:53, , 15F
05/14 23:53, 15F
→
05/14 23:54, , 16F
05/14 23:54, 16F
推
05/14 23:55, , 17F
05/14 23:55, 17F
→
05/14 23:59, , 18F
05/14 23:59, 18F
→
05/15 00:01, , 19F
05/15 00:01, 19F
推
05/15 00:03, , 20F
05/15 00:03, 20F
推
05/15 00:09, , 21F
05/15 00:09, 21F
→
05/15 00:10, , 22F
05/15 00:10, 22F
→
05/15 00:12, , 23F
05/15 00:12, 23F
推
05/15 00:12, , 24F
05/15 00:12, 24F
推
05/15 00:12, , 25F
05/15 00:12, 25F
推
05/15 00:13, , 26F
05/15 00:13, 26F
→
05/15 00:13, , 27F
05/15 00:13, 27F
→
05/15 00:13, , 28F
05/15 00:13, 28F
推
05/15 00:14, , 29F
05/15 00:14, 29F
→
05/15 00:14, , 30F
05/15 00:14, 30F
→
05/15 00:17, , 31F
05/15 00:17, 31F
→
05/15 00:17, , 32F
05/15 00:17, 32F
→
05/15 00:20, , 33F
05/15 00:20, 33F
推
05/15 00:21, , 34F
05/15 00:21, 34F
→
05/15 00:24, , 35F
05/15 00:24, 35F
→
05/15 00:25, , 36F
05/15 00:25, 36F
→
05/15 00:25, , 37F
05/15 00:25, 37F
→
05/15 00:28, , 38F
05/15 00:28, 38F
→
05/15 00:29, , 39F
05/15 00:29, 39F
還有 172 則推文
推
05/15 10:09, , 212F
05/15 10:09, 212F
推
05/15 10:12, , 213F
05/15 10:12, 213F
推
05/15 10:14, , 214F
05/15 10:14, 214F
→
05/15 10:15, , 215F
05/15 10:15, 215F
推
05/15 10:18, , 216F
05/15 10:18, 216F
推
05/15 10:24, , 217F
05/15 10:24, 217F
推
05/15 10:26, , 218F
05/15 10:26, 218F
推
05/15 10:26, , 219F
05/15 10:26, 219F
推
05/15 10:26, , 220F
05/15 10:26, 220F
推
05/15 10:27, , 221F
05/15 10:27, 221F
推
05/15 10:28, , 222F
05/15 10:28, 222F
→
05/15 10:47, , 223F
05/15 10:47, 223F
→
05/15 10:48, , 224F
05/15 10:48, 224F
推
05/15 11:07, , 225F
05/15 11:07, 225F
→
05/15 11:08, , 226F
05/15 11:08, 226F
→
05/15 11:08, , 227F
05/15 11:08, 227F
→
05/15 11:09, , 228F
05/15 11:09, 228F
→
05/15 11:11, , 229F
05/15 11:11, 229F
→
05/15 11:12, , 230F
05/15 11:12, 230F
→
05/15 11:13, , 231F
05/15 11:13, 231F
→
05/15 11:13, , 232F
05/15 11:13, 232F
→
05/15 11:14, , 233F
05/15 11:14, 233F
→
05/15 11:15, , 234F
05/15 11:15, 234F
→
05/15 11:16, , 235F
05/15 11:16, 235F
→
05/15 11:17, , 236F
05/15 11:17, 236F
→
05/15 11:18, , 237F
05/15 11:18, 237F
→
05/15 11:18, , 238F
05/15 11:18, 238F
→
05/15 11:19, , 239F
05/15 11:19, 239F
→
05/15 11:19, , 240F
05/15 11:19, 240F
→
05/15 11:21, , 241F
05/15 11:21, 241F
→
05/15 11:21, , 242F
05/15 11:21, 242F
→
05/15 11:22, , 243F
05/15 11:22, 243F
→
05/15 11:22, , 244F
05/15 11:22, 244F
→
05/15 11:22, , 245F
05/15 11:22, 245F
→
05/15 11:28, , 246F
05/15 11:28, 246F
→
05/15 11:28, , 247F
05/15 11:28, 247F
→
05/15 11:30, , 248F
05/15 11:30, 248F
→
05/15 11:39, , 249F
05/15 11:39, 249F
推
05/15 12:25, , 250F
05/15 12:25, 250F
→
10/07 20:51, , 251F
10/07 20:51, 251F
討論串 (同標題文章)
Realityshow 近期熱門文章
PTT影音娛樂區 即時熱門文章
88
152