Re: [討論] 來吧！年度回顧。

看板documentary (紀錄片)作者shihlun (shihlun)時間20年前 (2005/01/03 15:07)推噓2(2推 0噓 0→)

留言2則, 2人參與討論串6/6 (看更多)

※ 引述《echohihi (米米米你米米米米你....)》之銘言： : ※ 引述《shihlun (shihlun)》之銘言： : : marrakech，請問您看到的資料，是不是聞天祥這個網站上的影評？ : : http://movie.kingnet.com.tw/comment.html : : 假如是的話，well，我只能說他的猜想，是完全猜錯了 : : 這樣寫之前，他實在應該上網找找訪談，查查看影片基本資料的。 : : 兩位導演一開始就在德國寫好了劇本，腦子裡知道他們要的是什麼 : : 然後再去找適合的對象演出。選角兩週，拍攝七週，砰，完工 : : 根據他們的說法，他們運氣好，結果拍到他們設想的東西 : : 他們說他們的方法叫做narrative documentary : : 取法對象是紀錄片經典「北方的南奴克」 : : 那麼，對「北方的南奴克」的一些看法與意見，倒也同樣出現在這部電影上 : 我也來說一下~ : 我看的不是上述的文章 : 但內容也是說遇上母駱駝拋棄小駱駝的事是意外的 : 不是早就寫進劇本理的 : 我是看真善美牆上的影片介紹我想這就是台灣將錯就錯的電影文化戲院將錯就錯，片商糊里糊塗，觀眾老被誤導他們本來就是先寫好劇本，去那邊找一個家庭演，然後希望拍到被拋棄的小駱駝依照他們單方面的說法，裡面有運氣成分在裡面，尤其他們只拍了七週（不過劇本早就寫好了，也就不用跟正統紀錄片作法一樣必須取得被拍攝者的信任，長期「跟拍」，after all，他是把這些人當作演員）但要像台灣的文字資訊，說這是「意外」，「不小心碰到」，就有點奇怪了以下是導演自己的說法： LUIGI FALORNI: It all started from the music ritual, which is performed every now and then when a camel mother rejects her newborn, to convince her to accept it again. That was the starting point of the whole project. And that was also what got me interested in making the film. We decided from the very beginning to go for a mixture of strictly documentary observing on one hand, and also re-enacting on the other hand. We developed a fairly detailed script and went looking for the story that we had written, basically, in Munich, on a desk. Q:Did you go looking for this sort of mother/colt problem? What would you have done if it had not happened while you were there? What would your movie have been about? A:The musical ritual is being used in several cases. Off course we wanted the mother-colt problem to happen. ............This was pure luck. When you have a wish, the spirit will listen to you. Like my grandmother, I am a person with a deep faith. I need that. (...) Q:How many births did you film before finding the one that becomes the focus of your film? A:The initial plan was to start shooting at the beginning of April, but during our researches we found out that the birth of camels already starts in March. So we had to change all the plans and travel two weeks earlier. (...)Already in the first night after we arrived, a birth occurred, which we could film. It was a good practice and we had the first material for the editing room. There was a second birth the same night. (...) When the birth started. we were so tired that we didn't know if it was day or night. We filmed the second birth, and a white colt was born. The mother rejected it and this was our colt. ※ 編輯: shihlun 來自: 218.161.8.246 (01/03 15:28)