Re: [心得] 看完星際大戰六部曲與魔戒

看板StarWars (星際大戰)作者 (電光掲示板)時間13年前 (2012/12/14 23:11), 編輯推噓7(7016)
留言23則, 6人參與, 最新討論串3/3 (看更多)
: 推 rkl3329:預言中平衡原力的不是Luke嗎? 12/14 22:52 : → owenkuo:那就是EU的描寫了^^ 這篇回文一開始有說先略談EU 12/14 22:54 : → owenkuo:個人認為Ep6最後的演出只是稍稍的帶出這樣的概念。 12/14 22:55 : → biglafu:平衡原力的是Anakin吧.... 12/14 23:02 個人意見偏見人見智,這就是看電影和同好討論的樂趣:) (而不是只會指著角色說他中二....) 但,如果說要有個官方或半官方的說法.....那.... http://starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Chosen_One 在 Behind the scenes 這段 George Lucas himself has stated that Anakin is the Chosen One and that the prophecy is true, although it had been misinterpreted by the entire Jedi Order .................... This, however, was written in 1975, when the prophecy of the Chosen One had not been developed, and is actually referencing the actions of Luke Skywalker, not his father. 有興趣可以參考看看。 -- They're both convinced that a sudden passion joined them. 他們彼此深信,是瞬間迸發的熱情讓他們相遇。 Such certainty is beautiful, Wislawa Szymborska but uncertainty is more beautiful still. (辛波絲卡) 這樣的確定是美麗的,但變幻無常更為美麗。 "Love at First Sight" ~~Turn Left˙Turn Right 幾米~~ -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 114.40.151.56 ※ 編輯: owenkuo 來自: 114.40.151.56 (12/14 23:13)

12/14 23:18, , 1F
所以.....算是老爸還是兒子??
12/14 23:18, 1F

12/14 23:18, , 2F
(其實是Leia) (誤)
12/14 23:18, 2F

12/14 23:19, , 3F
老爸在事實行為上宰了白布丁(所以義憤殺人構成要件該當)XD
12/14 23:19, 3F

12/14 23:20, , 4F
兒子則在Ep6之後的很多事件,慢慢發展出New Jedi Order
12/14 23:20, 4F

12/14 23:20, , 5F
所以從形而上的角度來說,平衡是兒子作的事
12/14 23:20, 5F

12/14 23:21, , 6F
另外個人的理解,Jedi/Sith、原力光明面/黑暗面,
12/14 23:21, 6F

12/14 23:21, , 7F
不一定就是這樣一對一的相對應關係。不過這是我個人看法
12/14 23:21, 7F

12/14 23:22, , 8F
應該要請版上其他對EU更熟的版友來補充比較好 :)
12/14 23:22, 8F

12/15 00:11, , 9F
我覺得兒子老爸都有在平衡....
12/15 00:11, 9F

12/15 00:13, , 10F
有點文王/武王的感覺這樣(咦)
12/15 00:13, 10F

12/15 02:32, , 11F
我也覺得都有。不過原力平衡的定義...
12/15 02:32, 11F

12/15 02:32, , 12F
說不定Order 66那天滅了絕地就真的平衡一下了
12/15 02:32, 12F

12/15 10:00, , 13F
這個有點偷換概念,第二段明明就跟The Chosen One設定
12/15 10:00, 13F

12/15 10:00, , 14F
無關。
12/15 10:00, 14F

12/15 10:01, , 15F
老盧所謂的平衡,簡單講就是 Anakin 消滅的舊的
12/15 10:01, 15F

12/15 10:02, , 16F
Jedi/Sith勢力。他兒子是建立起新的不平衡(Light Only)
12/15 10:02, 16F

12/15 12:25, , 17F
原力平衡到底是甚麼? 有哪裡重要? 問一下
12/15 12:25, 17F

12/15 15:26, , 18F
嗯,我有段時間沒看EU了,不過最新的Fate of the Jedi系列
12/15 15:26, 18F

12/15 15:26, , 19F
似乎有Address這個問題
12/15 15:26, 19F

12/15 18:38, , 20F
新系列把Clone Wars S03E15那個世界拉進去講,大概就是說
12/15 18:38, 20F

12/15 18:38, , 21F
Anakin本可在那個地方變成真‧Chosen one,但他放棄了
12/15 18:38, 21F

12/15 18:40, , 22F
真邱森萬是說如果他繼承The Father的地位嗎???
12/15 18:40, 22F

12/15 20:40, , 23F
記得是這樣...
12/15 20:40, 23F
文章代碼(AID): #1Goq68Jj (StarWars)
文章代碼(AID): #1Goq68Jj (StarWars)