Re: [問題] 馬勒&布魯克納的版本

看板clmusic (古典音樂)作者ashkenazy (誰殺了古典音樂！)時間22年前 (2002/07/24 15:11)推噓0(0推 0噓 0→)

留言0則, 0人參與討論串1/3 (看更多)

※ 引述《Kremer (紐倫堡的名歌手)》之銘言： : ※ 引述《DreamBlack (金色轟炸機)》之銘言： : (omit) : : 如果你很堅持想自己買或是借不到 : : 那推薦你Bruckner可以買Jochum指揮德勒斯登的錄音 : : 是EMI的低價紙盒版應該不到1000元 : : Mahler就要看預算了 : Bruckner可參考Jochum指揮BPO與巴伐利亞廣播交響樂團錄的DG全集，以及上述。 : 當然，布魯克納全集很多，但是記得不要買蕭提的就是了。 : 馬勒的全集很多，我推薦的是鄧許泰特的emi超低價版和辛諾波里dg版， : 如果覺得不過癮，可以選擇Bernstein 在dg的版本。千萬不要買庫貝力克就是了就以馬勒全集來說大致上便宜的版本鄧許泰德(1300~1500) 11CD 這套便宜又大碗，錄音佳，詮釋嚴謹入門者強烈建議蕭提(1800~2000) 10CD 適合已經初步了解馬勒音樂的人不建議入門者，錄音極佳，風格暴力強烈，理性詮釋庫貝力克(1800~2000) 10CD 錄音算是偏差，亦適合入門者風格隨性所至，行雲流水海丁格(1800~2000) 10CD 錄音佳，在當時可謂相當傑出，入門者不適合風格為理性中帶點輕鬆中等價位的版本辛諾波里(2700~3000) 15CD 錄音極佳，不適合入門解析式的詮釋試探聽眾的口味對不同口味的聽眾都可以接受包容阿巴多(3200~3400) 12CD 錄音中等，詮釋誠懇入門者強烈建議，非常忠實的表現出馬勒很貴的版本伯恩斯坦(4000~4500) 16CD 錄音佳，不適合入門，且價格昂貴但對於已經初步了解馬勒音樂的人是非買不可風格非常激情感性，甚至有瘋狂的傾向易白爾(6000~6500) ?CD 錄音佳，適合入門者，但價格相當恐怖詮釋平淡卻又輕鬆，理性而嚴謹塔巴可夫(6000~6500) 15CD 這就請ChaosCreator兄簡介一下了至於伯恩斯坦在CBS的全集我找了好久都沒看過所以也不清楚大約價位多少小弟所說的適合入門者與否並未帶有太多個人意見純粹是就馬勒本身的音樂來出發因為對於曲子本身就已經不熟的入門者而言如果給予太強烈的指揮個人色彩反而會影響聽者對音樂本身的認知與了解甚至是被指揮給誤導了尤其是伯恩斯坦的版本更是如此大家聽一聽感覺都是很爽很讚可是在企鵝評鑑中伯恩斯坦的版本卻表現不好台灣跟日本都有相當多的聽眾為伯恩斯坦抱屈然而其實伯恩斯坦的詮釋可謂過分扭曲馬勒的原意而是否馬勒的音樂是否會令人著迷呢？小弟的答案是肯定的看看有多少人在瘋狂收集馬勒就知道了至於非全集的馬勒版本如下如果有闕漏的也請各位版友幫忙補齊一下吧 Symphony No. 1 Minneapolis SO/Mitropoulos 1940 VSO/Horenstein 1953 NYPO/Walter 1955 VPO/Kubelik 1956 LPO/Boult 1958 VPO/Kletzki 1960 LPO/Scherchen 1960 SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1961 Columbia SO/Walter 1961 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1962 BSO/Leinsdorf 1963 LSO/Solti 1964 NYPO/Bernstein 1966 Halle/Barbirolli 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 ONF/Markevitch 1967 RAI Turin SO/Markevitch 1967 LSO/Horenstein 1969 CSO/Giulini 1971 LSO/Levine 1975 Boston SO/Ozawa 1977 LSO/Fabermann 1979 CSO/Solti 1983 Philadelphia/Muti 1984 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1985 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987 BPO/Abbado 1989 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1989 Prague Festival/Urbanek 1989 Minnesota SO/de Waart 1989 Cleveland/von Dohnanyi 1989 CSO/Tennstedt 1990 CBSO/Rattle 1991 NYPO/Masur 1992 Florida PO/Judd 1993 Royal SNO/Jarvi 1993 Danish National RSO/Segerstam 1993 Symphony No. 1 Titan (1893 version) NPO/Morris 1970 Symphony No. 2 Resurrection Unknown/unnamed orchestra/Fried 1923 VPO/Walter 1948 Concertgebouw/Klemperer 1951 Columbia SO/Walter 1958 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1960 LSO/Stokowski 1963 NYPO/Bernstein 1963 Philharmonia/Klemperer 1963 Bavarian Radio SO/Klemperer 1965 Utah SO/Abravanel 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1969 Stuttgart Radio SO/Barbirolli 1970 LSO/Bernstein 1973 BBC SO/Boulez 1973 Symphonica of London/Morris 1978 LPO/Tennstedt 1982 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985 CBSO/Rattle 1986 NYPO/Bernstein 1988 LSO/Kaplan 1988 San Francisco SO/Blomstedt 1992 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1992 Polish National RSO/Wit 1993 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2002 Symphony No. 3 Wiener Konzertverein/Adler 1953 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 Utah SO/Abravanel 1969 BPO/Barbirolli 1969 LSO/Horenstein 1970 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973 CSO/Levine 1975 LPO/Tennstedt 1979 VPO/Abbado 1982 NYPO/Bernstein 1987 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994 Symphony No. 4 New SO of Tokio/Konoyo 1930 Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1939 NYPO/Walter 1946 Berlin Radio SO/Klemperer 1956 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1957 CSO/Reiner 1958 Cleveland/Szell 1966 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 LPO/Horenstein 1971 CSO/Levine 1975 BPO/Karajan 1979 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1983 CSO/Solti 1983 VPO/Maazel 1984 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1987 SWDR SO Baden-Baden/Gielen 1988 LPO/Welser-Most 1988 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1991 LAPO/Salonen 1992 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1992 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2000 Symphony No. 5 NYPO/Walter 1947 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952 BSO/Leinsdorf 1963 NYPO/Bernstein 1964 ORTF/Scherchen 1965 BBC SO/Boulez 1968 NPO/Barbirolli 1969 BBC SO/Boulez 1970 CSO/Solti 1970 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1971 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1973 Symphonica of London/Morris 1974 LSO/Schwarz 1975 Philadelphia/Levine 1978 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1985 VPO/Bernstein 1988 LPO/Tennstedt 1988 RPO/Inoue 1990 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1990 Finnish RSO/Saraste 1991 BPO/Abbado 1994 Concertgebouw/Chailly 1998 Symphony No. 5 (Adagietto) Concertgebouw/Mengelberg 1926 VPO/Walter 1938 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959 Symphony No. 6 WDR SO/Mitropoulos 1959 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Stockholm PO/Horenstein 1966 NPO/Barbirolli 1967 NYPO/Bernstein 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 NPO/Barbirolli 1969 BPO/Karajan 1978 LSO/Levine 1979 LPO/Tennstedt 1983 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1986 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1986 VPO/Bernstein 1988 RPO/Inoue 1988 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1989 BPO/Haitink 1989 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1990 LPO/Tennstedt 1991 Royal Scottish National O/Jarvi 1992 Polish National RSO/Wit 1992 VPO/Boulez 1994 Symphony No. 7 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950 Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1952 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1960 Utah SO/Abravanel 1965 Toronto SO/Scherchen 1965 NPO/Horenstein 1969 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970 RAI Milan SO/Maderna 1971 CSO/Levine 1980 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1982 CSO/Abbado 1984 NYPO/Bernstein 1985 CBSO/Rattle 1991 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991 Netherlands PO/Haenchen 1992 LPO/Tennstedt 1993 Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1994 Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand PSONY/Stokowski 1950 LSO/Horenstein 1959 LSO/Bernstein 1966 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1970 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971 CSO/Solti 1971 Symphonica of London/Morris 1973 VPO/Bernstein 1975 BBC SO/Boulez 1975 Opernhaus- und Museumsorchester Frankfurt/Gielen 1981 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1990 BPO/Abbado 1994 Gothenberg SO/Jarvi 1994 Colorado MahlerFest Orchestra/Olson 1995 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1993 Concertgebouw/Chailly 2001 Symphony No. 8 Symphony of A Thousand (Part 1) Berlin Staatskapelle/Scherchen 1951 NYPO/Bernstein 1962 Symphony No. 9 VPO/Walter 1938 Vienna SO/Scherchen 1950 Vienna SO/Horenstein 1952 RAI Turin SO/Barbirolli 1960 Columbia SO/Walter 1961 BPO/Barbirolli 1963 Czech PO/Ancerl 1966 LSO/Horenstein 1966 Orchestre National de France/Horenstein 1967 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1967 NPO/Klemperer 1968 American SO/Horenstein 1969 BBC SO/Boulez 1972 RAI Turin SO/Maderna 1972 BPO/Karajan 1982 Concertgebouw/Bernstein 1986 Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986 VPO/Abbado 1987 RLPO/Pesek 1990 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1991 Philharmonia/Sanderling 1992 Moscow Radio SO/Barshai 1993 Polish National Radio SO/Halasz 1993 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1993 NYPO/Masur 1994 Symphony No. 10 (Adagio) Vienna State Opera/Scherchen 1953 Leipzig Radio SO/Scherchen 1960 Czech PO/Neumann 1966 Bavarian Radio SO/Kubelik 1968 LSO/Boulez 1971 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1971 VPO/Bernstein 1974 VPO/Abbado 1985 Frankfurt RSO/Inbal 1986 Philharmonia/Sinopoli 1987 Bamberg SO/Rickenbacher 1988 Czech PO/Pesek 1989 Danish National Radio SO/Segerstam 1994 Polish National Radio SO/Wit 1994 Symphony No. 10 (Cooke) Philadelphia/Ormandy 1965 Berlin SO/Sanderling 1979 Berlin RSO/Chailly 1986 Frankfurt Radio SO/Inbal 1992 Das Lied von der Erde VPO/Walter 1936 VPO/Walter 1952 Concertgebouw/van Beinum 1957 Philharmonia/Kletzki 1959 SWDR SO/Rosbaud 1959 NYPO/Walter 1960 VSO/Klemperer 1961 NPO/Klemperer 1964 Concertgebouw/Jochum 1965 Czech PO/Neumann 1966 Philadelphia/Ormandy 1966 VPO/Bernstein 1967 VSO/Kleiber 1967 Cleveland/Szell 1970 Israel PO/Bernstein 1972 BBC Northern SO/Horenstein 1972 Concertgebouw/Haitink 1976 LPO/Tennstedt 1982 Czech PO/Neumann 1983 BPO/Giulini 1984 Cologne Radio SO/Bertini 1991 National SO of Ireland/Halasz 1994 -- ※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc) ◆ From: 163.31.116.93 ※ 編輯: ashkenazy 來自: 163.31.116.93 (07/24 15:11)