Re: [轉錄][閒聊] 台灣文革
看板media-chaos (媒亂(媒體亂象))作者urban (經營職棒要有良心)時間18年前 (2007/03/17 11:25)推噓2(2推 0噓 4→)留言6則, 4人參與討論串1/2 (看更多)
※ [本文轉錄自 KMT 看板]
作者: urban (經營職棒要有良心) 站內: KMT
標題: Re: [轉錄][閒聊] 台灣文革
時間: Sat Mar 17 11:21:56 2007
※ 引述《npchen (np)》之銘言:
: ※ [本文轉錄自 HatePolitics 看板]
: 作者: jerrytang (jerry) 看板: HatePolitics
: 標題: [閒聊] 台灣文革
: 時間: Sat Mar 17 10:31:26 2007
: http://www.economist.com/world/asia/displaystory.cfm?story_id=8861553
: CHIANG KAI-SHEK may once have been revered as a near-god on Taiwan, where he
: led his Chinese Nationalist regime after being defeated by Mao Zedong's Com
: munists on the mainland in 1949. But almost a third of a century after his d
: eath, the memory of the old dictator is being effaced, with the removal of t
: he generalissimo's statues and the renaming of many streets and even Taipei'
: s international airport.
這段是說過去台灣把老蔣幾乎都做神來看
他雖然輸給老毛,可是他的獨裁政權在台灣被美化
然後他的名字出現在台灣很多街道跟台北的國際機場
但近三分之一世紀之後,開始被消除
: No longer mournedThis has provoked a political row, which this week engulfed
: Taiwan's defence minister, Lee Jye. He was expelled from the Kuomintang (KM
: T), Chiang's former ruling party, for allowing statues of the old nationalis
: t to be removed from Taiwan's military bases.
這段是在講李傑被老K踢出家門
只是因為他拆了銅像引起老國民黨員的不爽
: Chiang's legacy has never been properly examined in Taiwan. Arguments about
: the past are also fights over what the island should be in the future: a par
: t of China (the view of Chiang Kai-shek and his political heirs), or an inde
: pendent nation with a distinct, non-Chinese Taiwanese identity.
這段更有趣了
「在台灣,老蔣的遺產從來沒有被清楚的計算過」
但依據後文,遺產應該是指老蔣的「遺志」
可能是指根本沒人知道老蔣是認為台灣是中國一部份還是該建國
(這段挺詭異的)
: The current government of President Chen Shui-bian, whose Democratic Progres
: sive Party (DPP) leans towards independence (but which appointed a KMT man a
: s defence minister), intensified its campaign against the generalissimo as t
: he island marked the 60th anniversary of the 録28 Incident钗the KMT's violen
: t suppression of protests against its rule on February 28th 1947. An estimat
: ed 28,000 were killed.
這段是在說二二八事件中有約兩萬八千人死於國民黨的暴力鎮壓
: Blaming the massacres on Chiang and the 団utside鐠regime of the KMT, the DPP
: announced plans to rename the giant Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall in Taipei
: as the 荘aiwan Democracy Memorial Hall鐬 and tear down the sanctuary's peri
: meter wall. The central government dropped 静hina鐠from the names of many st
: ate enterprises last month. There is talk of removing Chiang's portrait from
: Taiwanese coins.
這段是寫說民進黨要譴責蔣政權跟老K的外來政權
其中經濟學人把中正紀念堂形容成「聖殿」
基本上這就已經是個諷刺......
: DPP leaders may be politicking ahead of parliamentary elections in December,
: and presidential polls next March. But there is more at stake. By casting t
: he 228 Incident as a clash between Taiwanese and KMT 団utsiders鐬 the DPP ha
: s not only opened old wounds in Taiwan but also created anxiety in Beijing.
: China's Communists may have been at odds with the generalissimo. But they fe
: ar that Taiwan, by breaking with Chiang's legacy, may also be breaking away
: from the Chinese mainland.
這段前面是在說民進黨的四大天王都在為了民調跟初選努力
後面則是說到中國的想法,雖然中國也很討厭老蔣
但他們懼怕台灣這種去蔣的模式會在中國發酵(促成去毛去共產黨?)
大略看了一下抓了幾個重點
全文看不出有譴責台灣政府去蔣的論點
標題的Cultural Revolution跟中國的文革也一點關係都沒有
聯合報引用這個文章是搞笑嗎?
如果這個全文翻譯在聯合報上
我看馬上會被愛國同心會踏平吧XD
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 203.73.233.4
※ 編輯: urban 來自: 203.73.233.4 (03/17 11:24)
--
※ 發信站: 批踢踢實業坊(ptt.cc)
◆ From: 203.73.233.4
推
03/17 11:37, , 1F
03/17 11:37, 1F
→
03/17 11:42, , 2F
03/17 11:42, 2F
→
03/17 11:51, , 3F
03/17 11:51, 3F
→
03/17 11:52, , 4F
03/17 11:52, 4F
推
03/17 20:22, , 5F
03/17 20:22, 5F
→
03/17 20:23, , 6F
03/17 20:23, 6F
討論串 (同標題文章)
完整討論串 (本文為第 1 之 2 篇):
104
342
media-chaos 近期熱門文章
PTT影音娛樂區 即時熱門文章